The Great Pumpkin Lives!

For Linus of Peanuts fame, Halloween was all about the pumpkins—and unshakable faith in one in particular. Would you, too, wait through the night in a worthy patch for the mysterious Great Pumpkin’s annual return? Or go for the candy?

It’s said that Jack of lantern fame was once a real person who made a bad deal with the devil. He ended up forever doomed to roam the earth the night before All Souls Day, with only a candle in a turnip to light his way. To protect against Jack, and any nasty spirits, people carved their own gourds—turnips, radishes, potatoes—with terrifying faces. Then they added candles to represent the souls trapped in Purgatory and placed the jacks in windows or outside their homes.

Brrr. Not exactly the tame jacks of my childhood. But each year, it’s the spirit of the pumpkin—along with the stringy, yellowish guts and smell of melting wax—that holds fascination for me. Or maybe it’s just the faces.

My dad, also named Jack, shared my love of grinning gourds. Selecting worthy pumpkins to carve was a ritual for us every year.

Dad was extremely picky about our choices, although our jacks always turned out exactly the same. Triangle eyes, circle nose, jagged mouth with missing teeth. I drew the face and Dad did the cutting.

The night before Halloween, my mom fled to the other end of the house while my dad and I destroyed the kitchen with gloppy pumpkin guts and slimy seeds. Not to mention all that test smoke from the test candles. I think I was trying for the same expression in this pic. Note the lovely 60s curtains.

We placed our creations on the stone wall in front of our house. One year, they were attacked by stick-brandishing hooligans. I was as crushed as the pumpkins when I saw the slippery remnants at the bus stop the next morning.

The next year we displayed our jacks on TV trays on the patio. I kept vigil by the window after I finished trick-or-treating. Later, our valiant jacks died slow, painful deaths on Corelle Ware plates in the kitchen. First, little black dots appeared. Then the sides crumpled, twisting mild expressions into gnarly, evil scowls. At that point, my orange charges simply vanished, never to be seen again. My mother blamed their disappearance on the dog (note fearsome poodle below).

Many Halloweens have come and gone. But each year when the scent of chrysanthemums and wet leaves fills the air and the nights fall sooner and colder and darker, it’s time for the truest, worthiest jacks to return. This year, the youngest member of our family (she’ll be 3 weeks old) will receive her first pumpkin.

Happy Halloween, Everyone!

Readers, are you celebrating with any pumpkins this year (or have you in the past)? Most importantly, do you believe in the Great Pumpkin?

30 thoughts on “The Great Pumpkin Lives!”

  1. No pumpkin carving here. I’m terrible at it. One year, we did buy and paint faces – but getting rid of the rotten pumpkins four weeks later was awful. The Boy carved them one year – but still had the disposal issue.

    1. Ugh, Liz, pumpkin rotting is horrible. It gets so cold here shortly after Halloween that sometimes we have a little extra time before that happens. Not always, though…

  2. What a great post! I love the photos.

    We never carved pumpkins growing up but we did a couple of times with Eliza. The best was one that looked like a bat, so it looked like we were sending up the Bat signal from our courtyard.

    1. Bat pumpkins–so fun! I think I may have a stencil somewhere, but so far I’ve stuck to faces, ha.

  3. Love these pictures, Lisa! Pumpkin patches were really popular in my childhood, so we often picked the gourds and carved faces (the smiley ones like yours) in them. It was only later when my husband came on the scene (note: he does all the intricate ones) that we branched into designs like Totoro–that’s been my fave so far. Alas, with the kids getting older, we’ve had less enthusiasm for pumpkin carving, so the tradition has been fading.

    1. Totally get it, Jen! We used to do a lot of pumpkin seed roasting with the carving process, but now we just dump it all out, ha.

  4. Of course, I believe in the Great Pumpkin. But I don’t spend the night in a pumpkin patch. It’s not that I don’t believe. I just need my sleep.

    I carved pumpkins as a kid, but I’ve never done it as an adult. Mine always looked remarkably like what you describe, except we did triangles for noses, too. No circles for us.

    1. Mark, hilarious! I need my sleep too. I also believe in the Great Pumpkin–and the Tooth Fairy and the Sand Man. Actually, I believe in most of the characters from the Rise of the Guardians animated feature film. Of course, if you tell anyone that, I’ll have to deny it. Ha!

      1. Patricia, I believe in all of them, too. So much that I was very wary of either the Tooth Fairy or the Sandman sneaking into my bedroom. The cash tooth reward was great, but I dreaded possibly meeting an actual fairy in the dark.

    2. Much easier to cut triangles, Mark! Our circles never came out that great. Also the top–the worst was when the stem popped off, or the lid didn’t fit back on right. Also, agree on the pumpkin patch sleepover. Would be pretty chilly here, ha.

  5. Fun post, Lisa! Thank you, and thank you for sharing those great pictures. So heartwarming. We don’t have what I’d call Halloween traditions. However, for the past few years, I’ve included promotional materials for my local library’s children’s books and activities in little sandwich bags with the candies I give the trick or treaters. Subliminal message: You want me to give you candy? Fine. I want you to read a book. Ha!

    1. Sounds like a great Halloween tradition to me, Patricia! What a sweet idea–and even more important these days.

  6. We have a friend who used to host a grand pumpkin carving extravaganza at his house over a two-day period, and one year we ended up with several hundred Jack oʻlanterns, which he displayed in his front yard on Halloween. Truly amazing.

    Here in Hilo, pumpkins are very expensive, so we settle for passing out candy to kids who come to our house dressed as dinosaurs, Darth Vader, and space aliens.

    1. I would have loved that pumpkin party, Leslie! There’s something about all those glowing jacks in the dark that is so inspiring and beautiful–maybe it’s the light, not really the carving.

  7. I have two large, Home Depot-grade jack-o-lanterns that sit on our porch through October. Come November, we turn them around facing the wall and voila, Thanksgiving decor! Fun reminiscence — we never did them growing up, but I do love them!

    1. Home Depot-grade, ha! But seriously, that is a brilliant decor tip. Wow. (Maybe there’s some way to outfit them for Christmas…)

  8. Lisa – Love the pics through the years. And for telling the story on how Jack of lantern fame was the start of the Halloween tradition. That was news to me!

    I also love carving pumpkins. But in Chicagoland the squirrels like to challenge us. They seem to think the line of carved lit pumpkins on our front porch are an invitation to an open buffet. They’ve also figured out how to blow out the candles inside and take off the tops before diving in. We end up with a view of squirrel butts and tails wagging in glee as they indulge themselves before we shoo them off. And then they come back and we shoo them off., etc. It’s never ending. Good news, our trick or treaters love seeing their hijinks and that makes it fun for us.

    Lastly, congratulations to all on your newest family addition. What a wonderful tradition to start her off with her very first pumpkin!

    1. Thank you, Debbie! I forgot to add that the tale of Jack O’ Lantern (aka Stingy Jack) originated in Ireland. It’s funny you mentioned the squirrels because my daughter sent me a photo of a very well-fed squirrel attacking the pumpkin on her porch steps in NJ. I had to laugh atthat bushy tail sticking out! But wow, blowing out the candles–that’s amazing! Also…clever. I had no idea.

  9. Lisa – Yes, squirrels are clever critters. But in thinking more about them blowing out the candle trick, I must confess I never SAW them blow out the candles. Just assumed they did. (Was probably the wind). If your daughter sees definitive proof her NJ squirrels can, let me know!! 🎃🐿️

    1. She is very annoyed with those squirrels. They’re pretty smart, because they’re showing up earlier each year now.

Leave a Reply